Monday, April 22, 2024

Mawdryn Undead [Doctor Who, Story 125]

 

Mawdryn Undead by Peter Grimwade
1 - 9 February 1983
 

As we approach the middle point of Peter Davison's time as the Doctor, we'd expect the regulars to be known quantities by now. True enough, Sarah Sutton feels like she once again didn't get a whole lot to do as Nyssa, Tegan is rather short with everyone, and the Fifth Doctor seems curiously unconcerned with everything around him. Although this story is a considerable improvement on Grimwade's last serial, Time-Flight, it seems like a mastery of the main cast's characterization has not miraculously materialized in the interim.

Accordingly it's a bit odd that a new companion is being introduced when the existing characters already seem so inconsistent. Nevertheless, I find Turlough very interesting, and his introduction as a semi-antagonist rather than the traditional companion role is definitely interesting. The story draws a parallel between Tegan and Nyssa's distrust of Mawdryn as the fake Doctor and Turlough's introduction as a "false" companion which I find pretty neat.

Seeing the Brigadier is always a pleasure, and he brings a fair bit to the story. The time travel quandary centered on the split between 1977 and 1983, and his selves on either side, is a great plot beat, although it feels somewhat buried in the mix of everything else going on with this story.

All in all, I'd consider this one a fun story with some good ideas that stops shy of being great because it tries to do a little too much in its allotted time. It might grow on me with future viewings.

 Terminus is up next.

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 22 April 2024.)

No comments:

Post a Comment