Showing posts with label season seventeen. Show all posts
Showing posts with label season seventeen. Show all posts

Saturday, June 25, 2022

The Well-Mannered War [Doctor Who, Diversion 29]

The Well-Mannered War
17 April 1997

​

My expectations have been toyed with thoroughly! I thought that I had a firm idea of what this story was going for by the end of the first chapter, only to be taken through several twists in succession that completely upended my sense of what was going on. It was thoroughly enjoyable being so very wrong.

The initial impression of the "war" on Barclow makes it clear that the conflict is going to go hot in some way or another, but my assumptions about how it would went out the window pretty quickly. I was charmed by the Chelonians (but had a sense that I had obviously missed a couple of previous appearances that would have made me appreciate them more), and amused by the political satire inherent in the description of Metralubit's government, as well as Fritchoff's over-the-top Marxist jargon.

I didn't expect to be so floored by the concept behind the Darkness, a thoroughly chilling alien monster, and I expected the Black Guardian's role reveal even less. It's not really left field per se, since the details all match when you look back. I had to nod in admiration at how clever this particular twist was. I found this a nice callback to the conflict between the Fourth Doctor and the Guardian that we saw in Season Sixteen. (And which I know will be continued in some manner in a couple of seasons, but we're not thinking that far ahead yet.)

I greatly appreciated the "K9 for president" plotline, and the Femdroids (and their plan) were fascinating to me. But I have to say that by far the most interesting part of this story, despite its brevity, is its ending. The implicit meaning of this ending is kind of obvious on the face of it, because this story is both set in the gap between the Graham Williams and JNT eras, and was itself the last of the Virgin Missing Adventures before BBC Books took over. The delightfully ambiguous way that the story ends (complete with a cheeky fourth wall acknowledging remark from Romana that they'd be nothing more than fictional characters, if they ended up in the Land of Fiction as the Doctor predicts) leaves a strong impression.

All in all, a strong book, and a fitting coda to this particular era of the show. I'll rejoin you all for the Seventies roundup shortly.

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 6 October 2021.)

Shada (2017 DVD Edition) [Doctor Who, Diversion 28]

Shada by Douglas Adams
19 July 2017 (DVD Edition)

"I'm not mad about your tailor."​

I really went back and forth on whether or not to rate and include this story as a part of the Season 17 roundup. While it has the production code and filming dates to prove its credentials, it was also certainly never finished and only released in full, in any way, many years later. Still, it feels very much of a type with the rest of the season in spite of its incompletion. Whatever the case, it is a strange coda to this era because of the various ways in which it has been brought to audiences. It's quite ironic, actually - the story famous for never being released is now the most rereleased Doctor Who story.

The story itself is generally a charming one. The peaceful atmosphere of Cambridge University feels markedly different from the sci-fi settings common to this era, with only City of Death as this part of the story's close analog. Aside from that passing resemblance, the story is tonally of a kind with that previous serial, but feels quite different in its execution. For one thing, there is less of a conscious attempt to include jokes in the script - although there are some good ones regardless. In particular I found the professor's remark about trying to get undergraduates talking to each other banned quite funny. If I had to pinpoint the difference, this would-be finale six-parter is making more of an effort to be a grand-scale conclusion to the season, rather than whatever City of Death was being.

The side characters are quite good, especially the dotty Professor Chronotis. I also liked Chris Parsons, but thought he was a bit underused; it could have been nice to have more of the story from the perspective of this outsider/everyman character to draw more of a comparison with how absurd the Doctor's world is. A lot of the villain Skagra's scenes are animated, so I feel like it's hard for me to formulate an overall opinion. His costume is a little too much for me to find him threatening in his live-action scenes, but it looks a bit better in the animated ones.

On the soundtrack of this version: Mark Ayres does an excellent job of emulating Dudley Simpson's style. It almost slipped my mind to mention that we wouldn't be getting any more Dudley soundtracks, but it seems worth noting. This Doctor's era was almost entirely characterized musically by Simpson's work, and it is profoundly odd to think that we'll never have it again. Whether this will turn out for good or ill remains to be seen.

Although I adored the location scenes from Cambridge in the earlier half of the serial (the gondola, the bike chase, and any scenes on that gorgeous set for the Professor's TARDIS) the actual setting of the titular Shada failed to impress me much. It feels like not enough time or awe is spent on the place given the leadup, and I was certainly not too thrilled with the extensive scenes spent fleeing the Krargs.

Despite the story tapering off like this, I found it quite solid on the whole. It is a little sad that we never got to see this story fully fledged as a part of its intended season, but the 2017 release with the animated segments feels like a fairly complete way to enjoy Shada. If I had included this 138-minute omnibus with the other ratings, it probably would have enjoyed something like an 8.00.

Well, enough of these feverish ramblings. With the last sort-of-televised entry of the Seventies out of the way, there is one last literary interlude I had planned before all is said and done. The Well-Mannered War is next.

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 6 October 2021.)

Doctor Who, Season Seventeen

Although numerically speaking, Seasons Fifteen, Sixteen, and Seventeen have showed consistently lower averages for me than the preceding three seasons, I have to say that after the heavy-handed Hammer schtick of Seasons Thirteen and Fourteen, the Graham Williams era was a bit of a relief. Although the execution of the episodes themselves has been a bit slipshod in places, the general spirit of adventure and lighthearted focus have endeared themselves to me.

I think it's really a pity that circumstances so consistently conspired against this production team, and it makes me unhappy to think that Williams, who left us far too soon, was never accorded enough praise during his life for his work on the program. He made do with what he had, and the spirit and resolve shown in that is admirable.

Despite, again, Season Seventeen having the lowest average scores of any season so far, I hope that this does not give the impression that I was dissatisfied with it. This is mostly a result of Destiny of the Daleks dragging the rest down like a dead albatross. On the whole, I was very pleased with the tone and the humor of this season, and expect to revisit it again in the future.

Here's the score breakdown:

Destiny of the Daleks - 4.50
Episode One - 6.00
Episode Two - 5.00
Episode Three - 4.00
Episode Four - 3.00

City of Death - 10.00
Part One - 10.00
Part Two - 10.00
Part Three - 10.00
Part Four - 10.00

The Creature from the Pit - 7.00
Part One - 8.00
Part Two - 7.00
Part Three - 7.00
Part Four - 6.00

Nightmare of Eden - 7.75
Part One - 8.00
Part Two - 8.00
Part Three - 7.00
Part Four - 8.00

The Horns of Nimon - 5.75
Part One - 7.00
Part Two - 6.00
Part Three - 5.00
Part Four - 5.00

Best episode: City of Death, Part One - 10.00
Runner-up: City of Death, Part Four - 10.00
Worst episode: Destiny of the Daleks, Episode Four - 3.00

Season Seventeen average: 7.00

Best guest appearance: Julian Glover as Scaroth of the Jagaroth (City of Death)
Best special effect: The Jagaroth spaceship exploding (City of Death)
Best musical score: City of Death (Dudley Simpson)

The "best of" segment wasn't really intended as a City of Death runaway awards show, but so fall the chips.

Say, isn't there a sixth story missing from this little lineup? That, like time, is relative, but Shada is next anyway.

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 6 October 2021.)

The Horns of Nimon [Doctor Who, Story 108]

The Horns of Nimon by Anthony Read
22 December 1979 - 12 January 1980​

I hope I do not overly damn this story with faint praise when I say that it's at least never boring.

I felt that The Horns of Nimon had a pleasingly grubby and desperate feeling at the beginning when we first see the decrepit Skonnan spaceship and the "sacrifices" on board. It's a feeling which is especially magnified by the hostility between the nameless co-pilot and our heroes later on, which makes things feel particularly dire. But as soon as the story ends up on Skonnos, all of these stakes and the tone it had been building up seemed to dissipate for the most part. It's really quite disappointing, because I think this story almost succeeds in being good.

The concept behind the Nimon themselves is interesting enough, their locust-like swarming from planet to planet to sap its life force shown in bleak detail during Romana's brief visit to Crinoth. Their voices even sound kind of cool, but I just can't take that costume seriously. Some effort was made, to be sure, but their bodies just look too small for their heads. I feel that hulking minotaur monsters ought to be a bit more heavily built. They just toddle around awkwardly instead.

After dipping into disappointing territory in some respects, the story manages to parabolate back into some level of enjoyability again by way of Soldeed. The performance behind him is so absurdly over-the-top that it gets the eyes rolling at times, but at least it kept them open. It was thoroughly memorable, I'll give it that.

I thought Lalla Ward was quite good in this story. She has a number of moments where she takes charge of the situation and gets quite domineering, enabled by the Doctor's general absence from the narrative for the first two episodes. I also find her red coat very pleasing to look at. Where's the Romanadvoratrelundar fashion catalog?

In the end, this is not a special story by any means, but it is at least not an awful one. It takes a sort of outsized importance by accidentally being the end of several historiographical eras, including the Graham Williams era and Seventies Who generally.

Despite my vague waffling earlier on, the real plan always was to end the "Seventies Who" leg of the marathon with this as its last televised story (notwithstanding the fact that this serial very rudely edges into the earliest days of 1980). So with a doff of my imaginary hat, I mark this occasion with gusto, appreciative of the fact that I've successfully cleared a second decade of televised Doctor Who.

But we aren't quite at the end yet. There are still two dangling threads, and two of those funny little roundup posts, too. Stay tuned.

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 6 October 2021.)

The Nightmare of Eden [Doctor Who, Story 107]

Nightmare of Eden by Bob Baker
24 November - 15 December 1979

"Well, I told you. I'm from Galactic."
"Galactic went out of business twenty years ago."
"I wondered why I hadn't been paid."​

I notice that we are now absent one Dave Martin, but in terms of the type of story being told, this story feels like a natural descendant of the Bristol Boys' other Doctor Who output. I have often pointed at these stories as having solid sci-fi ideas which fall apart in the execution, but Nightmare of Eden is more successful in this respect than most.

Despite airing during a season which has been characterized as a fairly light and silly one, the subject matter of this serial is surprisingly dark. The issues of narcotics and the hard opiate epidemic are still a pressing matter today, particularly where I live. Several members of the same graduating class I was a part of ended up overdosing over the last few years. I did not know any of them personally, but this topic still seems to land closer to home than most.

The social causes of addiction aren't really the focus here, more their societal effects. I was particularly attentive to this story's criticism of the sort of policing that usually arises in response to drug epidemics, and was amused by the Doctor's acerbic remark that bureaucrats are "worse than idiots".

Hamming it up when he's being "torn limb from limb" aside, I like the Doctor in this story. It's always nice when he takes up a bit of a sleuth's role, as I think it's a part Tom Baker plays quite well. His two-word response to Tryst's plea for understanding at the end of the serial is quite effective.

I have to admit that I took a pretty long time to twig onto the fact that Tryst was the baddie, and longer still to realize Dymond was in on it. I am nothing if not oblivious, but at least it means I get the full effect of the reveal. Considering that quirky professorial figures are usually posed in complementary or friendly roles with respect to the Doctor, it is actually sort of clever to have the main antagonist turn out to be one for once. Tryst's motives are almost understandable - but his actions monstrous enough that the Doctor's gruff goodbye to him seems more than justified.

The mandrels are nothing special as a monster, but are memorable on a visual level, particularly those glowing green eyes of theirs. The rest of the serial is less visually memorable as it takes place largely on one of a couple different ship sets, but the CET's views of alien worlds and the visual of Dymond's spaceship wedged just outside of the forcefield will both stick in my mind.

In terms of miscellany that stuck out to me, I enjoyed a dark chuckle at the doped-up captain's dismissive remark that the passengers are "only economy class" when the mandrels are ripping them apart. I also laughed out loud the first time a mandrel disintegrated and turned into crack. That probably wasn't the intended effect, but the absurdity of the realization just overcame me.

All in all, a solid enough serial, and a decent occasion for Bob Baker to bow out of the series on. His and Dave Martin's contributions have been a worthy inclusion in the Doctor Who canon, and thanks are owed.

Speedily on to the next. The Horns of Nimon wait for no man.

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 6 October 2021.)

The Creature from the Pit [Doctor Who, Story 106]

The Creature from the Pit by David Fisher
27 October - 17 November 1979​

I can't help but to feel that fandom is a little hard on this story. Although it's not a standout, I think this is a relatively solid, average-to-good Doctor Who serial. The plot raises eyebrows in places, but The Creature from the Pit is just good fun, as far as I'm concerned, and so I had no trouble simply sitting back and enjoying it.

It's a fairly well-directed story, with decent lighting and camerawork. This is the last outing of the long-tenured Christopher Barry, who first joined the Who directorial gang with The Daleks way back in 1963. His work has been, on the whole, pretty good, so on this occasion I salute him.

I quite like how lush the jungles in this episode look, and while the titular pit is indeed just another tunnel, the interior sets that make up Adrasta's palace look really good. The inhabitants of the planet are all fairly vibrant, from the domineering Adrasta and her sniveling subordinate Karela, to the Huntmaster and the humorous bandits. Geoffrey Bayldon steals the show as Organon, whose line "... the present, apologized for," gave me more than a small chuckle.

The concept behind the Tythonian ambassador being captured and posed as a monster recalls Ambassadors of Death, which did this particular thread much better, it has to be said. Still, although I have to blush and look away from the Creature more often than not (deary me!) it remains an interesting component of the story.

Admittedly, my one big foible with this story is that it feels like the plot has already wrapped up by the end of Part Three, but it keeps going for another 25 minutes anyway. This makes Part Four feel kind of puzzling, although the space action is kind of neat.

It's interesting to think that this is Lalla Ward's first story recorded as Romana. She's visibly not as at-ease as she was in the two previous stories I reviewed, but nevertheless seems to immediately understand how to mix her arch and playful tendencies to come across well on screen.

I'm indifferent to K9's new voice. It doesn't sound quite right to me since I'm so accustomed to John Leeson, and I have to say that it's missing the more understated sarcasm inherent in Leeson's interpretation that often comes out. Maybe it'll grow on me.

All in all, a decent addition to the canon and a positive sign that this season has more to offer aside from just City of Death.

Nightmare of Eden is next.

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 4 October 2021.)

City of Death [Doctor Who, Story 105]

City of Death by Douglas Adams, Graham Williams, and David Fisher
29 September - 20 October 1979

"Is no one interested in history?!"​

Everyone loves this, right? I'm sure that rare species who doesn't like City of Death exists, but I have never encountered him in his natural setting. Perish the thought, though; this is one of the most charming stories in the show's entire run.

This is yet another of that motley collection of Classic Who stories which I've already watched previously. In its own context, I found considerably more to appreciate about it, particularly by contrast with the dull serial before it. Lighthearted, clever, and endlessly nice to listen to and look at, it has basically all the makings of a classic. Don't expect me to suddenly bust out any contrarianism here; it really is that good.

Tom and Lalla have an obvious and immediate chemistry that adds to the charm of their Parisian vacation in Part One. After several seasons where we've spent most of our time in space, it is a little curious to see a contemporary Earth setting, with more Seventies haircuts and outfits than you can shake a stick at. It gifts the story with an air of authenticity. I enjoy the touch of the poster with a prehistoric human we see in passing, which dovetails neatly into the story's subplot of the origins of life on Earth.

Julian Glover couldn't be more perfect as Scaroth, and effortlessly transitions from the urbane Scarlioni to moments of abject madness, both in and out of a mask. The Countess and (especially) Duggan are memorable, playing marvelously caricatured takes on their respective archetypes that are just perfect for this sort of heist pastiche.

I was impressed by the transitions between sets and location filming; the sets look fairly genuine for what they're supposed to be, and everything feels visually cohesive. The music is also immaculate, definitely Dudley's best score for the program.

Among other bits and bobs, I was amused by the Doctor's remark about the fractured timepiece being a good likeness of a Time Lady, lest we forget that, at least by the reckonings of some stories and some expanded universe material, Time Lords are a bit more uncanny and eldritch than their human-ish faces imply. The Doctor's chinwag with the Borgia guard and the scene where the multiple Mona Lisas are uncovered behind the brick wall were some of my favorites.

I wish they could all be this fun, entertaining, and witty. But if they were, then sadly City of Death would no longer be as special! This must stand as one of the highlights of Tom's run. On to The Creature from the Pit next.

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 4 October 2021.)

Destiny of the Daleks [Doctor Who, Story 104]

Destiny of the Daleks by Terry Nation
1 - 22 September 1979

I don't think this story lands with the anticipated effect when you're marathoning the series. It's not so much "Oh boy! The Daleks are back!" as "Oh right, I guess it has been a while." I wouldn't say that I've particularly missed the Daleks; their last starring role was a bit of a dud, and Genesis of the Daleks was more effective for their relative scarceness. Unfortunately, it seems like this latest installment was not the occasion for the revival of their importance to the series.

This definitely does feel like Terry Nation working his notice, as it is in fact his last contribution to the series. He's gifted several good-to-great stories to Doctor Who during his tenure, and I've spoken in his defense before, but this story, alas, shows absolutely none of his good points as a writer.

It is rather annoying that this story makes the categorical and repeated mistake of treating the Daleks like robots. You'd think that making this mistake so regularly would be impossible when the author is the one who invented them, but nevertheless, here we are. It's kind of absurd when the story insinuates that the Daleks are only capable of machine logic and that all of their decision making, even their battle strategy, depends on computers. This is contradicted by pretty much every Dalek story before and since, so as a premise it simply boggles the mind. My only assumption is that this story was originally written with two different warring robot factions in mind, and that the Daleks were just written in at the eleventh hour because there was a box that needed to be checked.

The inclusion of Davros is also a bit bewildering. The feats of explanation that are taken to justify his presence when he clearly dies at the end of Genesis come across a little hollow, and the idea that he's so eager to rejoin the Daleks when they exterminated him, last he remembers, is more than a bit laughable. David Gooderson does well, but can't quite measure up to the Davros actors on either side of him.

The Movellans are memorable enough, although I felt like their history and motivations were left frustratingly vague. It's nice that they, and most of the extras in this story for that matter, are more diverse in race and gender than we've tended to see in the past.

The setting isn't much to look at. Skaro is neither as threatening as it was in Genesis or Evil of the Daleks, nor is it as alien was it was in their maiden outing. The first episode is enticing in places, promising mysteries about the story that will unfortunately never pan out, with the scenes of the Doctor and Romana exploring this "new" planet really the only riveting parts of the serial.

The one breath of fresh air is Romana. Lalla Ward doesn't have a lot of great moments in this story necessarily, but seems to be handling her Time Lady promotion well. Her lovely pink coat is the only thing keeping my eyes on the screen for most of its runtime. The jokes and short scenes inserted by newly inaugurated script editor Douglas Adams try desperately to elevate the rest, to mixed results.

Not a favorite. Wake me up when they're doing something cool with the Daleks again. The infinitely more pleasing City of Death is next.

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 4 October 2021.)