Showing posts with label marathon organization. Show all posts
Showing posts with label marathon organization. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 5, 2024

A Word on Robert Holmes

 A Word on Robert Holmes

 
Back in Monochrome Malarkey, I resolved to periodically memorialize cast and crew of Doctor Who when their time with the series ended. In practice, most of these have been for the Doctors themselves, doubling as roundups for their eras. The last time I felt it essential to sit down and do it for someone behind the camera was for Verity Lambert, way back in 1965. Since then, some other important figures in the show's history have come and gone. For many of them, I didn't feel it necessary to dedicate more than a paragraph or two, or else their work would continue after the cancellation of the show during the "Wilderness Years".

Robert Holmes is a different figure entirely, and while abler pens than mine have tried to pay him tribute, I still intend to join the choir praising him with as clear a voice as I can manage.

Holmes was a man who always marched to the beat of his own drum. Joining the army at the tender age of 18 under false pretenses, Holmes became the youngest officer in the British Army during his time serving in what is today Myanmar. After the war, he spent a spell as a police officer in London before becoming fascinated with the written word and resigning. His previous work fueled his early televisual career, writing for police serials, but Holmes eventually came to spend more time writing science fiction than anything else.

His work on Doctor Who spans 73 episodes written by him directly, and many more for which he was the script editor. It's almost impossible for me to imagine what the show might have been like without his influence. The list of concepts he either originated or shaped by introducing them in his scripts is a long one, including such important things as the basic picture of Gallifrey and the Time Lords, the Autons and Sontarans, even the Master to some extent.

His impact is easy to understand, but getting a read on him as a person is somewhat more difficult, as he left little behind except for his body of work. I was able to dig up a handful of interviews, where he mostly talks about his work on Who; I get the sense that he was very proud of it, and that it let his best writing habits flourish. He admitted that it could be difficult to write for at times, "because you’re in between Grand Guignol gothic horror on one side, and Monty Python on the other." But he must have liked it, or he wouldn't have kept coming back, even, in the end, at the cost of his own health.

Holmes cheerfully confessed: "I’m not a serious writer. I like to get some fun out of what I’m writing." His twisted sense of humor shows frequently in his work, but also in his commentary about it, seen here when discussing Terror of the Autons:

I was sitting opposite Ronnie Marsh, the then Head of Serials, across an acre of polished maple. He started telling me about the guidelines he felt the programme should follow. ‘Two or three seasons ago,’ he said, ‘we had some clot who wrote the most dreadful script. It had faceless policemen in it and plastic armchairs that went about swallowing people. I might tell you, there were questions in the House. Mrs. Whitehouse said we were turning the nation’s children into bed-wetters’. Could it be that he was referring to my ‘Terror of the Autons’? ‘Tut, tut’, I muttered, feeling the job slipping away. ‘how awfully irresponsible’.​

Beyond his own words, he is mostly memorialized through the words of those who worked with him, buried within so many DVD commentaries and "Behind the Sofa" featurettes which I can't get at from the work desk I'm writing this on. What is clear from the ones I can call to memory is that he was a brilliant guy as well as a good writer, and that he was missed terribly by all of them. Beyond his own tenure as script editor, he seemed to get on with all the others he interacted with like a house on fire: from Donald Tosh when he first attempted to submit a script in 1965, to Terrance Dicks, to Anthony Read and even Eric Saward.

Later generations of Who writers who grew up with his work pay him high accolades as well. Russell T Davies, no slouch of a writer himself, had this to say:

When the history of television drama comes to be written, Robert Holmes won't be remembered at all because he only wrote genre stuff. And that, I reckon, is a real tragedy.

It is remarkable in the extreme that somebody whom I suspect to be one of the greatest television writers of the last century has remained in such obscurity outside of this fandom. He could have done anything, but he did Doctor Who, out of what appears to be a sense of honest affection for the program. I think we must all consider ourselves very lucky to have had him.

Farewell, Mr. Holmes, and thanks for all the memories.

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 5 June 2024.)

Tuesday, June 4, 2024

Doctor Who, Season 23


Well, let's have a quick chat about this out of the narrative world, too. As the last season of Doctor Who that I'd never watched, The Trial of a Time Lord was always going to fill a bit of an interesting spot in the marathon: the last of the unknown, and a chance to end the first leg of this marathon (the leg where I mostly had no idea what to expect) on either a high or a low.

You know what? I liked it. The season was made by the seat of the production team's pants, which makes it suffer in some ways, but in others gives it a sort of madcap energy that I find downright infectious. The feeling is one of a show desperately trying to rediscover its identity, while not yet discovering a new direction to go in. It feels like a more successful spin on the previous season's formula, but it is very much still the same formula.

I've given Eric Saward a bit of grief in my reviews, but I do think he's a good writer. He just displays some bad habits in his Who writing that occasionally get in the way of true greatness. As a script editor, I perhaps don't rate him as highly as his predecessors or successors in the role, but he deserves some praise for patching the holes in the rapidly sinking ship that was this period until he couldn't anymore. His departure leaves the program in a bit of an odd state, but we'll pick up on that some more once we actually make it to the next season. It will fall to his successor to find that new direction that the show needs.

In order, I praise The Mysterious Planet for being a quite solid Holmes story, and his last full one for the program; Mindwarp, even though its brutality (physical and emotional) is awe-inspiring, for being an absolutely uncompromising watch that left me on the edge of my seat; Terror of the Vervoids for its mystery plotting and classic sci-fi vibes; and The Ultimate Foe for its bonkers and surreal first episode, if for nothing else. It must be said that the season absolutely fails at sticking the landing, partly on account of Saward's unexpected departure, but for a first-time viewer who isn't spoiled on everything (just some things!), it is decidedly entertaining.

We start to see a new Colin here, just a little more cuddly; still pompous and outspoken, but generally nicer and funnier than his counterpart from the previous season. His new dynamic with Peri is short-lived, but very sweet, and what little we get of him with Mel is fun, too. I think it's a pity he didn't get to continue this in the TV series, but as we'll see very soon, his future has vindicated him indeed.

Well, enough waffling. Here's the score breakdown:

The Mysterious Planet - 8.25
Part One - 10.00
Part Two - 8.00
Part Three - 7.00
Part Four - 8.00

Mindwarp - 8.50
Part Five - 8.00
Part Six - 9.00
Part Seven - 8.00
Part Eight - 9.00

Terror of the Vervoids - 8.00
Part Nine - 8.00
Part Ten - 8.00
Part Eleven - 8.00
Part Twelve - 8.00

The Ultimate Foe - 7.00
Part Thirteen - 9.00
Part Fourteen - 5.00


Best episode: The Trial of a Time Lord, Part One - 10.00
Runner-up: The Trial of a Time Lord, Part Eight - 8.00
Worst episode: The Trial of a Time Lord, Part Fourteen - 5.00

Season 23 average: 8.07

Best guest appearance: Michael Jayston as the Valeyard (The Trial of a Time Lord)
Best special effect: The Lukoser prosthetic (Part Five)
Best musical score: Parts 1 - 4 (Dominic Glynn)

Coming up next, the first of two memorial posts. Be seeing you soon.

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 5 June 2024.)

Monday, May 6, 2024

Doctor Who, Season 21


I've committed a small crime by including The Five Doctors in this season even though it's a special, and not technically part of any season. It's a crime which I'll repeat many, many times for my own convenience, I promise.

Season 21 is quite the interesting beast, boasting a few very high quality stories mixed in with some relative duds. At the very least, none of them were forgettable. This last stretch of the Davison era has been a roller coaster, including the great stories, the misses, and the one-by-one departures of its TARDIS team until we're left with Colin's Doctor and Peri in a very curious coda.

On the whole, this mixed record gave the season a noticeably lower score average than the two seasons before it, but I still think I'll remember this experience fondly, if only because it marked the time where I managed to get back into the swing of this marathon. Finally!

Here's the score breakdown:

The Five Doctors - 9.00

Warriors of the Deep - 5.25
Part One - 6.00
Part Two - 6.00
Part Three - 4.00
Part Four - 5.00

The Awakening - 7.50
Part One - 7.00
Part Two - 8.00

Frontios - 9.00
Part One - 9.00
Part Two - 9.00
Part Three - 9.00
Part Four - 9.00

Resurrection of the Daleks - 5.00
Part One - 6.00
Part Two - 4.00

Planet of Fire - 6.25
Part One - 7.00
Part Two - 5.00
Part Three - 6.00
Part Four - 7.00

The Caves of Androzani - 10.00

Part One - 10.00
Part Two - 10.00
Part Three - 10.00
Part Four - 10.00

The Twin Dilemma - 5.75
Part One - 6.00
Part Two - 6.00
Part Three - 5.00
Part Four - 6.00


Best episode: The Caves of Androzani, Part Four - 10.00
Runner-up: The Caves of Androzani, Part Three - 10.00
Worst episode: Resurrection of the Daleks, Part Two - 4.00

Season 21 average: 7.16

Best guest appearance: Christopher Gable as Sharaz Jek (The Caves of Androzani)
Best special effect: The petrified Time Lords (The Five Doctors)
Best musical score: Frontios (Paddy Kingsland)

Before we move on to Season 22, our 1984 Cities Made of Song post is coming up next.

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 6 May 2024.)

A Word on Peter Davison

 


​
I wasn't sure what to expect from the Fifth Doctor going into this era. Everything I'd heard about his stories from fandom osmosis always made him sound rather staid and boring, by the usual standards I've judged my favorite Doctors by.

It is true that this Doctor doesn't have the bombastic personality of the Fourth, but upon actual inspection of the episodes, rather than just relying on the written lore, there is a lot more depth and texture to Davison's performance as the Doctor than I suspected. He's a phenomenal actor, and while the scripts he has been handed weren't always the best, he has certainly made the most of them.

The Fifth Doctor was a little fuzzy to me as a character for much of this stretch of the marathon. It's sad he's going when he is, because it feels like he only really started to gel with the scripts and show what he could really do in his last season (barring some small glimpses before). That's why Big Finish exists, I suppose. I'll be gratified to be able to dive deeper into Davison's audio stories now that I'm through with his TV episodes.

Apologies are due, in other words, for me ever having doubts. He is great, and I understand the hype now, even if his era was a little bit hit and miss. Not his fault! (Why do I have the strangest reverse déja vu, as if I'm going to be saying this again sometime?)

----​

Several companions have come and gone during this latest Doctor's tenure, so it's time for yet another update to the top ten companions list. Let's see how things shake out:
  1. Barbara Wright
  2. Jo Grant
  3. Romana II
  4. Jamie McCrimmon
  5. Vislor Turlough
  6. Steven Taylor
  7. Liz Shaw
  8. Leela of the Sevateem
  9. Vicki Pallister
  10. Sarah Jane Smith
It's getting harder and harder to break into the top ten as the years go by. This time the sole casualty is the ever-dependable Ian, who drops down to 12th place out of view, just behind Tegan who is at 11th.

Tegan was a pretty great companion, but is let down, especially in her first season, by some daft writing choices and poor direction that doesn't really let her thrive. Like Nyssa, she enjoys a somewhat better afterlife in the world of audio dramas, but as I don't really rate based on those I couldn't place her higher.

Nyssa, I've talked about at length already, but is in much the same position as Tegan, just with less screen time overall in which to get to know her. I am fond of Nyssa just the same and look forward to exploring more of her latter-day stories.

Adric was never going to have a look in on the top ten. The attempt to make a younger and less mature companion is laudable, but Matthew Waterhouse didn't seem to know how to play that role without also coming across as rather snotty and unlikable. I think it's a wonder the Fourth Doctor and Romana II didn't drop him off somewhere well before he got himself blown up.

Kamelion is a non-companion who doesn't bear much further discussion beyond what I've said already.

Turlough was the real surprise for me. Starting off as an antagonist, his crisis of conscience and gradual adoption into the Doctor's little family was a brilliant piece of storytelling. His occasional cowardice is a very interesting trait for a companion, especially whenever he overcomes it, and I enjoyed the way his story evolved over time very much. Such a weird, unique companion! I can't help but to be fascinated with him.

Peri has only been with us for a short time now, so I'll reserve my judgement for the time being. I hope she'll get some more flattering moments in the next season.

----
​
Without further ado, here's the traditional "best of" reel:

The Doctor: There's always something to look at if you open your eyes!​
- from Kinda

The Doctor: When did you last have the pleasure of smelling a flower, watching a sunset, eating a well-prepared meal?
Cyberleader: These things are irrelevant.
The Doctor: For some people, small, beautiful events are what life is all about!
- from Earthshock

 

The Doctor: Well, there's a probability of anything. Statistically speaking, if you gave typewriters to a treeful of monkeys, they'd eventually produce the works of William Shakespeare.
Nyssa: [trying to draw the Doctor's attention away from his conversation with Tegan to the approaching craft on the viewscreen] Doctor...
The Doctor: Of course, you and I both know that at the end of a millennium they'd still be tapping out gibberish.
Tegan: And you'd be tapping it out right alongside them. I only asked you a simple question.
- from Mawdryn Undead

 

Peri: Doctor, why do you wear a stick of celery in your lapel?
The Doctor: Does it offend you?
- from The Caves of Androzani

 


----
​

With all that said and done, we bid farewell to this version of the Doctor for now, and move on to his more colorful successor. The Twin Dilemma is up next.

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 6 May 2024.)

Thursday, April 25, 2024

Doctor Who, Season Twenty


I'm not sure this season really hit the "only classic Doctor Who enemies" requirement it set out for, but that's really no mark against it. It was a fairly competent season overall and didn't need any such anniversary year gimmicks to help it along.

The Black Guardian plotline was a bit interesting, but seemed frequently overshadowed by the stories it ran across. It did, however, make for a good introduction to Turlough, who has swiftly proven my favorite Fifth Doctor companion. (But who knows? Maybe Kamelion will grow on me?

Anyway, here's the score breakdown:

Arc of Infinity - 7.00
Part One - 7.00
Part Two - 7.00
Part Three - 7.00
Part Four - 7.00

Snakedance - 10.00
Part One - 10.00
Part Two - 10.00
Part Three - 10.00
Part Four - 10.00

Mawdryn Undead - 6.75
Part One - 7.00
Part Two - 7.00
Part Three - 6.00
Part Four - 7.00

Terminus - 6.50
Part One - 7.00
Part Two - 6.00
Part Three - 6.00
Part Four - 7.00

Enlightenment - 9.00
Part One - 9.00
Part Two - 9.00
Part Three - 9.00
Part Four - 9.00

The King's Demons - 6.00
Part One - 7.00
Part Two - 5.00


Best episode: Snakedance, Part One - 10.00
Runner-up: Snakedance, Part Four - 10.00
Worst episode: The Kings' Demons, Part Two - 5.00

Season Twenty average: 7.68

Best guest appearance: Lynda Baron as Wreck (Enlightenment)
Best special effect: The sailing ships (Enlightenment)
Best musical score: To be honest, I didn't take special notice of any.

The Five Doctors is next.

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 25 April 2024.)

Thursday, August 17, 2023

Doctor Who, Season Nineteen


The shape of Eighties Who has quickly become apparent over the course of this series. Following the blueprint left by Season 18, Season 19 has tried a lot of new things, although its success has been mixed. The overall quality of the episodes is good enough, but the standoffishness of this TARDIS crew has kept me from warming to them as I would have liked. With Adric now out of the picture, I wonder how the remaining leads are going to develop.

With that short dissection out of the way, here's the score breakdown:

Castrovalva - 7.50
Part One - 7.00
Part Two - 7.00
Part Three - 8.00
Part Four - 8.00

Four to Doomsday - 7.25
Part One - 8.00
Part Two - 7.00
Part Three - 7.00
Part Four - 7.00

Kinda - 10.00
Part One - 10.00
Part Two - 10.00
Part Three - 10.00
Part Four - 10.00

The Visitation - 8.50
Part One - 9.00
Part Two - 8.00
Part Three - 9.00
Part Four - 8.00

Black Orchid - 7.00
Part One - 8.00
Part Two - 6.00

Earthshock - 9.50
Part One - 10.00
Part Two - 9.00
Part Three - 9.00
Part Four - 10.00

Time-Flight - 4.50
Part One - 6.00
Part Two - 4.00
Part Three - 4.00
Part Four - 4.00


Best episode: Kinda, Part Four - 10.00
Runner-up: Earthshock, Part One - 10.00
Worst episode: Time-Flight, Part Three - 4.00

Season Nineteen average: 7.81

Best guest appearance: Simon Rouse as Hindle (Kinda)
Best special effect: The Doctor's spacewalk (Four to Doomsday)
Best musical score: Castrovalva (Paddy Kingsland)

Season 20 soon, but first, Spare Parts is next. 

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 13 October 2022.)

Saturday, June 25, 2022

A Word on Tom Baker

A Word on Tom Baker​

The phrase "larger than life" is so often overused, but I feel it's impossible to go wrong when applying it to Tom Baker. Many actors in leading roles have rather oversized personalities, particularly in a show like Doctor Who which prides itself on the unusual and quirky. Baker still stands head and shoulders above the rest of them in that respect, and not just in the literal sense. It is this, in part, which has affixed him as the definitive Doctor in the minds of generations of fans, but that isn't the whole story. It helps that he's a tremendously capable actor, and one who was served well by some of the best seasons in the show's history.

That is not to say that his whole run has been comprised of the best seasons in the show's history. I disagreed with the tone of bits of the Hinchcliffe-Holmes era, and some episodes in the Williams era really were shockingly shoddy. But no matter how badly things went in the writer's room or the BBC boardrooms, you could be assured a certain level of quality simply by virtue of Tom's outrageous performances.

Such a small post is really no way to really measure the accomplishments of the Fourth Doctor era, but I hope it should suffice to say that even if this version of the Time Lord did not enter the ranks of my absolute favorites, it is very hard to imagine where Doctor Who would be without him.

-----​

Just like Pertwee before him, Tom has seen quite a few companions come and go, which has shaken up my companions ranking list a fair bit. Let's see what has changed since 1974.

  1. Barbara Wright
  2. Jo Grant
  3. Romana II
  4. Jamie McCrimmon
  5. Steven Taylor
  6. Liz Shaw
  7. Leela of the Sevateem
  8. Vicki Pallister
  9. Sarah Jane Smith
  10. Ian Chesterton

The only casualties are the Brig and Zoe, both fine companions in their own right, but the competition will only get more stiff from here on out.

Sarah Jane Smith remains at #9, but actually jumps ahead of two people after her second and third seasons on the show. She's tremendously likable, but I found it hard to say I liked her better than the others here. However, she is in the unique position of having several more seasons later in the marathon to ascend further. We wish her the best.

Leela charmed me a whole lot during her relatively short time on the show. Feisty and vivacious, and far outside of the norm for companions so far, she is immediately emblematic of her particular time on the show, and Louise Jameson is so lovely. I was very sorry to see her go when she did.

Romana I does not quite make it onto the list here. Mary Tamm put in a very convincing performance, but her single season wasn't quite enough for me to warm to her as I might have liked. It is especially hard with such a fantastic performance from her successor.

Speaking of whom, Romana II was a surprise and a delight. Her sense of style and her combination of aristocratic airs with cheeky playfulness were a winning combination of traits. The TARDIS team of her, Four, and K-9 is honestly hard to beat.

K-9 himself is a notable absence from this list, but please trust me when I say that I love that dog. (In fact, we're getting another dose shortly...)

Adric, Nyssa, and Tegan were omitted from my judgements when I compiled this list. They have simply not had the time to prove themselves yet. Expect to hear more over the course of the next few seasons.

-----​

It's hard to do a 'best of' reel for Tom without sounding like I'm cribbing notes from YouTube clip shows. And after all, it is a bit difficulty to pick "stand-out" moments from someone whose on-screen presence was pretty much always dialed to 11. Regardless, here are five of my favorite moments from Tom Baker's tenure as Doctor Who:

"Homo sapiens. What an inventive, invincible species." (The Ark in Space)

"Have I that right?" (Genesis of the Daleks)

"What do you do for an encore, Doctor?" "I win." (The Seeds of Doom)

"Would you mind not standing on my chest? My hat is on fire." (The Androids of Tara)

"Where are we going?" "Are you talking philosophically or geographically?" "Philosophically." "Then we're going to lunch." (City of Death)

-----​

And so the longest leg of this journey is at its end, and though I am sorry to bid farewell to the Fourth Doctor, I am excited to chart the unknown waters of the greater JNT era. Bye-bye, Tom! Bye-bye!

Speaking of unknown waters, though, I think I'm about to scupper myself on a deserted island just ahead. Doctor Who's first spinoff is next...

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 14 December 2021.)

Doctor Who, Season Eighteen

As far as a statement of intent from a new production team goes, Season Eighteen is a pretty good example of one that went right. Although I will happily defend the Williams era from the worst of its detractors, it is hard to deny the whiff of fresh air that wafts through with JNT's first season. Courtesy of the writers involved with this stellar season, it feels like there is a common thematic thread through all these episodes, something which is still rare in the show at this point. Although there were a couple of rough patches, it was a very solid year of Doctor Who.

That is where it rests as a prologue to the remainder of the Eighties, but what about as a coda for Tom? It does feel like he's working his notice at times, and everyone knows he was not particularly happy by the end. Still, although this feels very much apart from the seasons before it, it seems like this feeling of renewal is appropriate for the end of such a long reign.

Here's the score breakdown:​

The Leisure Hive - 8.00
Part One - 9.00
Part Two - 8.00
Part Three - 8.00
Part Four - 7.00

Meglos - 5.00
Part One - 5.00
Part Two - 5.00
Part Three - 5.00
Part Four - 5.00

Full Circle - 9.00
Part One - 9.00
Part Two - 9.00
Part Three - 9.00
Part Four - 9.00

State of Decay - 9.25
Part One - 9.00
Part Two - 9.00
Part Three - 10.00
Part Four - 9.00

Warriors' Gate - 10.00
Part One - 10.00
Part Two - 10.00
Part Three - 10.00
Part Four - 10.00

The Keeper of Traken - 6.75
Part One - 7.00
Part Two - 7.00
Part Three - 7.00
Part Four - 6.00

Logopolis - 9.00
Part One - 10.00
Part Two - 9.00
Part Three - 8.00
Part Four - 9.00

Best episode: Warriors' Gate, Part Four - 10.00
Runner-up: Warriors' Gate, Part One - 10.00
Worst episode: Meglos, Part Three - 5.00

Season Eighteen average: 8.14

Best guest appearance: Jacqueline Hill as Lexa (Meglos)
Best special effect: The Doctor is disassembled (The Leisure Hive)
Best musical score: Logopolis (Paddy Kingsland)

And now, to tip my hat to Tom. I will be along with that post shortly.

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 14 December 2021.)

Inauguration - End of Whovangelion, or: A Cruel PM's Thesis


Somewhere out there in the broader multiverse, there is a world where Doctor Who went on into the Nineties, where whether through luck or pluck it managed to keep limping on in an increasingly different and hostile television environment. We don't live in that world. In our world, bum luck and a couple of poor decisions doomed the show to go off the air right at the end of its third calendar decade. As of the latest point in my marathon, the show still seems to be hugely popular, so it's a little shocking to think that in just a few short seasons that will have reversed entirely.

However, I know better than to think that the show is bad when it's unpopular, and I'm terribly excited to explore what the so-called "JNT Era" has to offer. I have already seen all of Sylvester McCoy's episodes, but Peter Davison's and Colin Baker's tenures are a huge blank for me. Filling in this gap and completing Classic Who will be a big win for me.

The Cities Made of Song posts will be a scarcer species (in fact, the only one I have definitely planned is the one for 1981) but audios, books, and other extended media will continue to make regular appearances.

I'm very excited to get started. The Leisure Hive will kick things off next.

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 7 October 2021.)

Of Davros and Drashigs Roundup

Here sits a significant (albeit moved) goalpost in my marathon. As stated in the last inauguration post, the Seventies were sort of a black hole of Doctor Who knowledge for me - at once the most popular and beloved decade of the show's history, as well as the one of which I had seen the least. Now the hole is filled, and I feel more enriched for the experience.

On the whole, I have to say that the Pertwee era agreed with me more than the 6/7ths of the Tom Baker era that fall within this decade. Although both have been incredibly solid runs on the whole, the Pertwee era, by virtue of having the same production team almost all the way throughout, feels a bit more consistent. I've had my ups and downs with Tom, but in spite of those I've made a lot of new favorite stories along the way.

If I had to make a pronouncement about the general trends this decade of the program has shown, I would say that we have witnessed the show's blossoming into an enduring and multi-generational phenomenon. Although the core series mythology was first laid down in the Sixties, one cannot underestimate the amount of equally crucial elements that have appeared during these eleven seasons, from our first decent look at Gallifrey to key elements of the Doctor's character.

I am eager to see how Classic Who, as I left it in the first days of 1980, develops over its last decade.

-----​--

Here are my rankings of all 58 serials which aired during this era.

  1. Genesis of the Daleks - 10.00
  2. Carnival of Monsters - 10.00
  3. The Seeds of Doom - 10.00
  4. The Brain of Morbius - 10.00
  5. The Pirate Planet - 10.00
  6. City of Death - 10.00
  7. The Green Death - 9.83
  8. Spearhead from Space - 9.75
  9. The Robots of Death - 9.75
  10. Inferno - 9.57
  11. The Time Warrior - 9.50
  12. The Ark in Space - 9.50
  13. Doctor Who and the Silurians - 9.43
  14. Image of the Fendahl - 9.25
  15. Day of the Daleks - 9.25
  16. The Daemons - 9.20
  17. The Hand of Fear - 9.00
  18. The Horror of Fang Rock - 9.00
  19. Terror of the Zygons - 9.00
  20. The Face of Evil - 8.75
  21. Frontier in Space - 8.67
  22. Invasion of the Dinosaurs - 8.50
  23. The Three Doctors - 8.50
  24. The Ribos Operation - 8.50
  25. The Sea Devils - 8.33
  26. Terror of the Autons - 8.25
  27. The Claws of Axos - 8.25
  28. The Curse of Peladon - 8.25
  29. The Deadly Assassin - 8.25
  30. The Sun Makers - 8.25
  31. The Stones of Blood - 8.25
  32. The Ambassadors of Death - 8.14
  33. Pyramids of Mars - 8.00
  34. The Sontaran Experiment - 8.00
  35. The Invasion of Time - 7.83
  36. The Mutants - 7.83
  37. Planet of Evil - 7.50
  38. Nightmare of Eden - 7.50
  39. Planet of the Spiders - 7.50
  40. The Mind of Evil - 7.33
  41. Planet of the Daleks - 7.33
  42. The Masque of Mandragora - 7.25
  43. Revenge of the Cybermen - 7.25
  44. Robot - 7.25
  45. Colony in Space - 7.17
  46. The Creature from the Pit - 7.00
  47. The Androids of Tara - 7.00
  48. The Invisible Enemy - 6.75
  49. The Power of Kroll - 6.50
  50. The Android Invasion - 6.50
  51. The Time Monster - 6.17
  52. The Talons of Weng-Chiang - 6.00
  53. The Armageddon Factor - 5.83
  54. Death to the Daleks - 5.75
  55. The Horns of Nimon - 5.75
  56. The Monster of Peladon - 5.67
  57. Destiny of the Daleks - 4.50
  58. Underworld - 3.25
-----​--

Since I went to the trouble of doing so at the end of Monochrome Malarkey, I might as well post my general subjective ranking of how all of the seasons I've watched so far stack up against each other.

  1. Season Seven
  2. Season Twelve
  3. Season Two
  4. Season Ten
  5. Season One
  6. Season Sixteen
  7. Season Eight
  8. Season Thirteen
  9. Season Fifteen
  10. Season Seventeen
  11. Season Four
  12. Season Three
  13. Season Nine
  14. Season Six
  15. Season Fourteen
  16. Season Five
  17. Season Eleven

I think once I clear the Eighties that I should finally bite the bullet and switch to Arabic numerals for these typed season names. They are starting to get a bit cumbersome.

But never mind all that dross. I have done my share of housekeeping, and now bid this decade farewell. On to the next, and see you all then!

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 6 October 2021.)

Doctor Who, Season Seventeen

Although numerically speaking, Seasons Fifteen, Sixteen, and Seventeen have showed consistently lower averages for me than the preceding three seasons, I have to say that after the heavy-handed Hammer schtick of Seasons Thirteen and Fourteen, the Graham Williams era was a bit of a relief. Although the execution of the episodes themselves has been a bit slipshod in places, the general spirit of adventure and lighthearted focus have endeared themselves to me.

I think it's really a pity that circumstances so consistently conspired against this production team, and it makes me unhappy to think that Williams, who left us far too soon, was never accorded enough praise during his life for his work on the program. He made do with what he had, and the spirit and resolve shown in that is admirable.

Despite, again, Season Seventeen having the lowest average scores of any season so far, I hope that this does not give the impression that I was dissatisfied with it. This is mostly a result of Destiny of the Daleks dragging the rest down like a dead albatross. On the whole, I was very pleased with the tone and the humor of this season, and expect to revisit it again in the future.

Here's the score breakdown:

Destiny of the Daleks - 4.50
Episode One - 6.00
Episode Two - 5.00
Episode Three - 4.00
Episode Four - 3.00

City of Death - 10.00
Part One - 10.00
Part Two - 10.00
Part Three - 10.00
Part Four - 10.00

The Creature from the Pit - 7.00
Part One - 8.00
Part Two - 7.00
Part Three - 7.00
Part Four - 6.00

Nightmare of Eden - 7.75
Part One - 8.00
Part Two - 8.00
Part Three - 7.00
Part Four - 8.00

The Horns of Nimon - 5.75
Part One - 7.00
Part Two - 6.00
Part Three - 5.00
Part Four - 5.00

Best episode: City of Death, Part One - 10.00
Runner-up: City of Death, Part Four - 10.00
Worst episode: Destiny of the Daleks, Episode Four - 3.00

Season Seventeen average: 7.00

Best guest appearance: Julian Glover as Scaroth of the Jagaroth (City of Death)
Best special effect: The Jagaroth spaceship exploding (City of Death)
Best musical score: City of Death (Dudley Simpson)

The "best of" segment wasn't really intended as a City of Death runaway awards show, but so fall the chips.

Say, isn't there a sixth story missing from this little lineup? That, like time, is relative, but Shada is next anyway.

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 6 October 2021.)

The Key to Time [Doctor Who, Season Sixteen, Stories 98 - 103]

The Key to Time
2 September 1978 - 24 February 1979​

Well, this will be a bracing series of paragraphs, I can already tell. Why are all six of these stories clumped into one Frankenstein-ish post? Because I feel like it and I'm fresh back from a longer than average pause, that's why!

Coming into this season, I felt a mix of excitement and trepidation, but I at least knew I'd be off to a fairly solid start with The Ribos Operation. There is a certain level of quality implied in a Robert Holmes story, and I do feel like this one lives up to its positive fandom reputation. Among other important things, I got my first impression of "Romana I" through this story. Mary Tamm definitely gets a snobbish but likable character across successfully, and I got a strong first impression from this particular version of Romana.

The titular setting is a memorable one, with a distinct visual style right from the beginning, and some fascinating lore that unfolds throughout the course of the story. The guest cast is much celebrated by my fellow fans, and I can definitely see why. It took me an episode or so to really warm up to them, but I'll remember Binro the Heretic, the Graff Vynda-K, and Garron and Unstoffe fondly.

Holmes' usual wit is on display in moments like the one where the Doctor despairs the use of "gimmicky gadgets", which is an amusing position to take given that every gadget he ever uses is gimmicky, even K9.

I'll happily revisit this story again next time the fancy strikes me. It's a nice start that sets up the central storyline of this season well.

"He has departed, mistress."
"Well, that's obvious, but where?"
"To see a man about a dog."​

The Ribos Operation - 8.50
Part One - 9.00
Part Two - 8.00
Part Three - 8.00
Part Four - 9.00

-------------​

The term "guilty pleasure" does not really apply to my feelings about The Pirate Planet, because there's really nothing guilty about it. Studious readers will remember that this is one of two stories this season that I've reviewed before, although my perspective on it this time around couldn't be more different than my last. In anticipation of watching this season, I recently read James Goss' new(ish) novelization of The Pirate Planet, and to be honest, I fell a bit in love with it. My rewatch a few weeks later only validated this change in perspective, and I felt like I saw it in a new light.

Honestly, its plot is still held together by duct tape in places, but it all builds toward a logical conclusion that felt satisfying to me. I like the concept of the wandering planet devouring others for their resources. I really like the Captain, Fibuli, and their banter. And even though at the time of my first review I felt like Tom wasn't giving this story his all, I could see that he was eating it up in places. This last might just be a result of me being more used to his usual Baker-isms and style of acting than I was last time. Romana endeared herself to me further through the greater ease with which she interacts with the locals, as contrasted with the Doctor. They're a smart duo, and this is where I started to enjoy their double act a lot.

There is a consistent wit to this story which, although more understated than Douglas Adams' other big Who writing credit, endeared this story to me immensely, and I just had fun all the way throughout. The Pirate Planet is a new favorite of mine and I don't care who knows it.

"Dross and baubles!"​

The Pirate Planet - 10.00
Part One - 10.00
Part Two - 10.00
Part Three - 10.00
Part Four - 10.00

-------------​

At the halfway point, this season was at a promising three-for-three. Although I didn't think it was as good as the previous two stories, my first impression of The Stones of Blood was a positive one. I was predisposed to it because of its callbacks to the occult and ancient Celtic history, and the first two episodes are powerfully moody and mysterious. I enjoyed the cheek of this story being, as far as I'm aware, the first to point out the impractical shoes that the female companions of this era often have. Doesn't save poor Romana from being the victim of both of the first two cliffhangers, though.

The Ogri are an interesting monster, but the Cailleach didn't really convince me as a final antagonist. It has to be said that the court procedural of the second half of the story doesn't land anywhere near as well as the story's more down-to-earth first half, but overall I still thought that the story had a pretty strong core idea and enough memorable moments to make it feel worthwhile.

"I'm more from what you would call inner time."​

The Stones of Blood - 8.25
Part One - 9.00
Part Two - 9.00
Part Three - 8.00
Part Four - 7.00

-------------

The Androids of Tara is a perfectly serviceable story. The setting is fairly vibrant and memorable, there's a good guest cast (hello again for the last time, Cyril Shaps!), and the plot holds together rather well. Just the same, I found it pretty hard to get invested. Aside from obtaining the Key segment for this planet, a task which is handled in a fairly perfunctory way, I couldn't find much reason to care about the core plot. It essentially comes down to a dispute over which particular feudal despot will be in charge at the end of the story, and I don't find the fact that Prince Reynart is nicer than Count Grendel to be a particularly compelling reason to care.

Don't let this give the impression that I dislike the story, of course. It just happens to fall into the territory of fairly ordinary average-to-good Who for me, with some cool effects and funny moments. Nothing I'd put on my heavy watch rotation, though.

"We don't want him too intelligent, Doctor. You can't trust androids, you know."
"It's funny, you know. That's what some androids say about people."​

The Androids of Tara - 7.00
Part One - 8.00
Part Two - 6.00
Part Three - 7.00
Part Four - 7.00

-------------​

The Matrix tells me that I once reviewed The Power of Kroll as well, though to be honest, I barely have any memory of that occasion which is now more than four years past. Well, aside from that massive puppet and the miniature shots. Although these effects are frequently chuckled at, I feel like they kind of work for the sort of story this is. I'm still skeptical about whether or not the People of the Lakes succeed as an allegory for native rights and the related issues, but it's a little heartening that Holmes and the production team at least made an attempt.

I feel like Philip Madoc is a little wasted on his side role in this story, but he is still good, and I enjoyed seeing John Leeson in-person for once. The backstory about the People of the Lakes and how they came to be on Delta III was quite interesting. Probably the most enjoyable moment of the serial for me is the one where the Doctor is rambling about the architecture of the room where he and his compatriots are about to die, which I thought was quite funny.

All around though, my estimation of this story diminished slightly since my first watch. With the benefit of greater context, this story feels much more average by comparison, and didn't leave me with a terribly strong impression, whether negative or positive. Basically, it's fine.

"I tried to persuade Ranquin that only Rohm-Dutt deserved to be punished by the seventh ritual and that you others should die by the first. That's very easy. They just throw you down the pit and drop rocks on you."
"Oh, thank you. It's nice to know who your friends are."​

The Power of Kroll - 6.50
Part One - 6.00
Part Two - 6.00
Part Three - 7.00
Part Four - 7.00

-------------​

I find it hard to be too harsh on The Armageddon Factor, but it is impossible to deny that the Key to Time arc ends on a bit of a bum note with this story. This is yet another instance of a Baker & Martin script with some cool core sci-fi ideas that get drowned in the realization. I was certain going in that this story would be an allegory for nuclear war, with more attention paid to the clearly long and punishing conflict between Atrios and Zeos. But this whole thread really gets lost in the mix with the focus of the story turning almost wholly to the search for the last segment.

This story does benefit from some decent side characters in the form of Shapp and the Marshal. The former in particular is played by an actor with a strong grasp of the physical aspects of a performance, and I noticed that he bounced off of Tom Baker well with visual gags and expressions. Drax is more mixed, since he comes in so late, but is at least amusing for what little time we get him. Princess Astra is unfortunately an underwhelming first outing for Lalla Ward, who I think gets underserved by the script here.

The Shadow is a pretty crap villain, far too generically evil without at least having the courtesy to go full screaming ham and keep things interesting. And timeloop plot aside (which I thought was executed in an interesting way) the ultimate resolution involved in discovering the true identity of the last segment and then thwarting the Black Guardian went off with not so much a bang as a resounding wet splat. It definitely cheapens the value of the previous five stories to have things end this way - but oh well.

A farewell in two parts to round up this story review, then. First, farewell to Mary Tamm, who I thought was splendid as Romana. It is a pity that we did not have her longer, and that she passed away when she did. I unfortunately did not pencil in any Romana I audios for this marathon, so this is the last time we will be seeing her for now.

The other thing we're seeing the last of are the traditional six-parters. As you all undoubtedly know, one was produced for Season 17 but never finished - so it doesn't really count. With one other notable exception, we won't see another story of this length in Classic Who. This is probably a good thing, as I've made a point of talking about before.

All in all, a fairly meh story to herald the departure of that format, with some promising ideas but underwhelming execution.

"To halt the hated Zeons in their tracks, wipe their presence from our skies, and free this land, this world, this Atrios..."
"This Blessed Plot!"
"Good! Good! ...this blessed plot from the terrors of war and the evils of pestilence!"
"Yes! ... No, I prefer the original."​

The Armageddon Factor - 5.83
Part One - 8.00
Part Two - 7.00
Part Three - 6.00
Part Four - 6.00
Part Five - 4.00
Part Six - 4.00

-------------

Although I quibbled with the stories in the latter half of this season, I still feel like this was a more successful and cohesive experience than Season Fifteen was. It's clear Graham Williams went into this with a specific vision, and even though it stumbled at the last hurdle, I feel that the overall tone of the season came across successfully.

It's hard to believe I still have two more seasons of Tom after this. Seven years sure are seven years, huh? I'm not eager to see him go or anything, but it is profoundly odd to spend this many episodes with the same Doctor. He's not tackling things with the same verve he was during the Hinchcliffe years, but it is clear that he still has that magnetic charisma during these later seasons that makes it impossible to take your eyes off him.

Here's the score break-- erm, no, hold on. Those are all further up on this post. Cut to commercials, please.

Best episode: The Pirate Planet, Part Four - 10.00
Runner-up: The Pirate Planet, Part One - 10.00
Worst episode: The Armageddon Factor, Part Six - 4.00

Season Sixteen average: 7.54

Best guest appearance: Beatrix Lehmann as Professor Rumford (The Stones of Blood)
Best special effect: The Ogri (The Stones of Blood)
Best musical score: The Ribos Operation (Dudley Simpson)

I'm excited to see what the last season of the Graham Williams era has in store. Destiny of the Daleks is next-erminate.

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 3 October 2021.)

Doctor Who, Season Fifteen

Having finally watched this season, which has a mixed reputation among fandom, I have to say that its reputation is overstated. Although it is burdened by the interminably dull Underworld, the rest of the stories were perfectly serviceable at worst and excellent at best. I had a lot of fun with Season Fifteen, but it doesn't sound like the production team did if the stories are true. It seems fate conspired to doom Graham Williams' production - between the inflation crisis, the Mary Waterhouse business, and the arrival of Star Wars presaging a fresh onslaught from expensive American productions - so it's all the more remarkable that such a fun little season still came out of the chaos.

I'll be very much looking forward to Season Sixteen. I've already watched two stories from it (four years ago, for my aborted randomizer marathon) and will be interested to see it all in its proper context.

Anyway, here's the score breakdown:

Horror of Fang Rock - 9.00
Part One - 9.00
Part Two - 9.00
Part Three - 9.00
Part Four - 9.00

The Invisible Enemy - 6.75
Part One - 7.00
Part Two - 6.00
Part Three - 7.00
Part Four - 7.00

Image of the Fendahl - 9.25
Part One - 10.00
Part Two - 9.00
Part Three - 9.00
Part Four - 9.00

The Sun Makers - 8.25
Part One - 9.00
Part Two - 8.00
Part Three - 8.00
Part Four - 8.00

Underworld - 3.25
Part One - 5.00
Part Two - 3.00
Part Three - 3.00
Part Four - 2.00

The Invasion of Time - 7.83
Part One - 9.00
Part Two - 9.00
Part Three - 8.00
Part Four - 8.00
Part Five - 7.00
Part Six - 6.00

Best episode: Image of the Fendahl, Part One - 10.00
Runner-up: Horror of Fang Rock, Part One - 9.00
Worst episode: Underworld, Part Four - 2.00

Season Fifteen average: 7.42

Best guest appearance: Edward Arthur as Colby (Image of the Fendahl)
Best special effect: The Titan base goes up in smoke (The Invisible Enemy)
Best musical score: Horror of Fang Rock (Dudley Simpson)

Back to you again soon for The Ribos Operation. Cheers!

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 6 July 2021.)

Doctor Who, Season Fourteen

 

After a brief but eventful sojourn, I've arrived at the end of the Philip Hinchcliffe era of Doctor Who. Although Robert Holmes will remain with us as script editor for a few more stories (and will come back to write his own scripts independently for a while yet), his time shaping the direction of the program is also coming to a close here. It seems appropriate to reflect on this milestone as I finish up Season Fourteen.

Although I've talked about my issues with the content of the stories in this period (namely, that many of them have a tendency toward style without substance), there have been many exceptions, with thought-provoking stories like Genesis of the Daleks and The Face of Evil proving that the program still has its chops. The big area in which this era has been an unqualified success is in drawing once again on Doctor Who's literary roots in science fiction and horror, and using them to make the show scary again. Even the stories that I thought were missing that special something at least succeeded in that much.

The high levels of production value have also been a joy, though knowing what I do about the behind-the-scenes, that looming inflation crisis is looking like a Sword of Damocles for incoming producer Graham Williams. We wish him the best.

Here's the score breakdown:

The Masque of Mandragora - 7.25
Part One - 8.00
Part Two - 7.00
Part Three - 7.00
Part Four - 7.00

The Hand of Fear - 9.00
Part One - 9.00
Part Two - 9.00
Part Three - 9.00
Part Four - 9.00

The Deadly Assassin - 8.25
Part One - 9.00
Part Two - 8.00
Part Three - 8.00
Part Four - 8.00

The Face of Evil - 8.75
Part One - 9.00
Part Two - 9.00
Part Three - 9.00
Part Four - 8.00

The Robots of Death - 9.75
Part One - 9.00
Part Two - 10.00
Part Three - 10.00
Part Four - 10.00

The Talons of Weng-Chiang - 6.00
Part One - 6.00
Part Two - 6.00
Part Three - 6.00
Part Four - 6.00
Part Five - 6.00
Part Six - 6.00

Best episode: The Robots of Death, Part Two - 10.00
Runner-up: The Robots of Death, Part Four - 10.00
Worst episode: You know, I just chopped all the Talons episodes down to 6 on principle, put whichever of them here that strikes your fancy.

Season Fourteen average: 8.00

Best guest appearance(s): Christopher Benjamin & Trevor Baxter as Henry Gordon Jago & Professor Litefoot (The Talons of Weng-Chiang)
Best special effect: The robots! (The Robots of Death)
Best musical score: The Talons of Weng-Chiang (Dudley Simpson)

An exciting new leg of my adventure seems to be ahead of me. First, a detour away from the televised world (our first in a while!) to the audio story The Wrath of the Iceni. Until next time!

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 18 May 2021.)

Friday, May 7, 2021

Doctor Who, Season Thirteen

Well, I just spent a few sentences in the previous post talking about some of the things that bothered me about this season, so I might as well spend the actual Season Thirteen post extolling its virtues. There's a sense of confidence to this season that was missing from the previous, probably because Season Twelve was a transitional period, full of stories commissioned by the previous team. Philip Hinchcliffe and Robert Holmes are clearly doing their level best to scare the hell out of the kids watching at home, and to their credit, I can tell it worked like a charm.

With the exception of the fairly dull Android Invasion, every episode this season is a good one, continuing the good streak that's been (mostly) uninterrupted this decade. Here's hoping our eighth Seventies season will keep that going!

Here's the score breakdown:

Terror of the Zygons - 9.00
Part One - 9.00
Part Two - 10.00
Part Three - 9.00
Part Four - 8.00

Planet of Evil - 7.50
Part One - 8.00
Part Two - 7.00
Part Three - 7.00
Part Four - 8.00

Pyramids of Mars - 8.00
Part One - 9.00
Part Two - 8.00
Part Three - 8.00
Part Four - 7.00

The Android Invasion - 6.50
Part One - 8.00
Part Two - 7.00
Part Three - 6.00
Part Four - 5.00

The Brain of Morbius - 10.00
Part One - 10.00
Part Two - 10.00
Part Three - 10.00
Part Four - 10.00

The Seeds of Doom - 10.00
Part One - 10.00
Part Two - 10.00
Part Three - 10.00
Part Four - 10.00
Part Five - 10.00
Part Six - 10.00

Best episode: The Seeds of Doom, Part Two - 10.00
Runner-up: The Brain of Morbius, Part Four - 10.00
Worst episode: The Android Invasion, Part Four - 5.00

Season Thirteen average: 8.62

Best guest appearance: Gabriel Woolf as Sutekh (Pyramids of Mars)
Best special effect: The Zygon costumes (Terror of the Zygons)
Best musical score: Terror of the Zygons (Geoffrey Burgon)

That's all for now. Back again soon, once I've watched The Masque of Mandragora.

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 27 April 2021.)

Thursday, April 22, 2021

Doctor Who, Season Twelve

What an inventive, invincible season!

Season Twelve has quickly transformed Doctor Who into a cosmic adventure again, just as it was in the 1960s. It would be easy to attribute this to the new production team, but all of the stories of this production block were commissioned by Barry Letts and Terrance Dicks. Sort of a parting gift, then, and one which Hinchcliffe and Holmes handled with surprising grace, considering what a mess the production seems to have been.

Two more classic stories were given to us this season, plus three solid but less extraordinary entries to the canon. Here's the score breakdown:

Robot - 7.25
Part One - 8.00
Part Two - 7.00
Part Three - 7.00
Part Four - 7.00

The Ark in Space - 9.50
Part One - 9.00
Part Two - 9.00
Part Three - 10.00
Part Four - 10.00

The Sontaran Experiment - 8.00
Part One - 9.00
Part Two - 7.00

Genesis of the Daleks - 10.00
Part One - 10.00
Part Two - 10.00
Part Three - 10.00
Part Four - 10.00
Part Five - 10.00
Part Six - 10.00

Revenge of the Cybermen - 7.25
Part One - 7.00
Part Two - 7.00
Part Three - 8.00
Part Four - 7.00

Best episode: Genesis of the Daleks, Part One - 10.00
Runner-up: Genesis of the Daleks, Part Six - 10.00
"Worst" episode: The Sontaran Experiment, Part Two - 7.00

Season Twelve average: 8.60

Best guest appearance: Michael Wisher as Davros (Genesis of the Daleks)
Best special effect: The giant Robot K-1 (Robot)
Best musical score: Revenge of the Cybermen (Carey Blyton & Peter Howell)

Say, aren't we short somewhere between four and six episodes for this season? Why, yes... The last story of this production block was carried over into Season Thirteen to move Doctor Who back to an autumn start for the first time since 1968. We'd best get on with that. Terror of the Zygons is next.

(Modified from the original posted on Gallifrey Base on 18 April 2021.)

Wednesday, April 14, 2021

A Word on Jon Pertwee

 A Word on Jon Pertwee

So ends a remarkable period of Doctor Who history. For all that Hartnell and Troughton defined the role of the Doctor, neither ever inhabited the role in the same way that Jon Pertwee did. Allegedly, he was directed to "just play himself" when the question of how to characterize his version of the Doctor was brought up. And if that's true, then this man surely was the Doctor, unparalleled.

There are undoubtedly aspects of this Doctor (like his penchant for Venusian karate) that wouldn't hold up in present incarnations. But despite this, others, like his strong sense of moral outrage, his "citizen of the universe" attitude, and his love-hate relationship with humankind, are all still obvious today. He's a real hero, and it's been a joy watching his time on the show.

It's been an era of contradictions; a down-to-earth setting with unearthly characters, military orthodoxy with Buddhist mysticism, feminism and political activism with some misjudged moments. So too is this Doctor a man of contradictions, a gentleman in old-fashioned dress who is nevertheless just as much of a rebel as a scholar, establishment and dis-establishment wrapped up into one. Accordingly, it's one of the most fascinating portrayals of Doctor Who that's ever been given.

By all accounts, Jon was temperamental too, but a brilliant guy just the same, and a steadfast friend to his fellow cast members. He loved the role and served as an ambassador for the show for the rest of his life, and I'll always admire him for that.

-----​

Jamie seems to have set some kind of precedent, because like him, several characters have remained a part of the Doctor's extended family for rather a long time during this era. Accordingly, it feels more stable than, for example, the revolving door of the Hartnell years. They are a part of the glue that held these five seasons together, and I found all of them highly likable. Here's how my top ten companions are looking as of 1974.

  1. Barbara Wright
  2. Jo Grant
  3. Jamie McCrimmon
  4. Steven Taylor
  5. Liz Shaw
  6. Vicki Pallister
  7. Ian Chesterton
  8. Alistair Lethbridge-Stewart
  9. Sarah Jane Smith
  10. Zoe Heriot

Polly, Ben, Victoria and Susan all fall out of view, the poor things. I loved these new characters so much, though! Sacrifices must be made.

Liz Shaw made a strong impression despite her short stay. I thought her more mature outlook and her world-weary cynicism was a great fit for this proud and fussy Doctor. I'm going to need to hunt down more of Caroline John's Companion Chronicles appearances!

Jo Grant was a bit of a dark horse. First impressions in Terror of the Autons didn't fill me with a great deal of hope, but despite the tut-worthy way that she's written into Season Eight, the lovely Katy Manning elevated the role into one of the most likable characters the show has ever had. Over the course of her three seasons, Jo visibly developed and matured as a person, something that I can't take for granted this early in the show's history. She's undoubtedly one of the very best assistants this Time Lord could hope for.

The Brigadier has proved to be an able sidekick for the Doctor, a capable fellow who serves as the comic straight man to all the science fiction that follows our title character around. I confess a preference to those times where he wasn't actually fulfilling the role of a companion, however, namely his more antagonistic relationship with the Doctor in Season Seven. But regardless of the inconsistency of that particular thread, he'll always be a welcome presence on my screen.

Benton doesn't quite make the cut, but remains a thoroughly enjoyable character, while Yates likewise remains below the top ten, if indeed he can be considered a companion. Either way you slice of it, both of these UNIT boys likewise found a place in my heart.

Lastly, Sarah Jane, who's only just got here! I'm already charmed by her, but I don't feel that I'll have much else to say until she's had a couple seasons with Tom to develop some more.

Pertwee's era wouldn't have been the same without this family of characters. I think this is the sort of thing Chris Chibnall aims for with his large ensemble casts, but the closest thing to this in the New Series which actually succeeds is the RTD era. Since I whetted my Who appetite on those years of the post-2005 program, this feels rather familiar and welcoming to me. Although some of the UNIT guys will be around for a little while yet, this marks the point where that family becomes divided, and it's sad to see it go.

-----​

Here are five of my favorite moments from Jon Pertwee's tenure as Doctor Who:

"What are you a doctor of, by the way?" "Practically everything, my dear." (Spearhead from Space)

"Hello! Are you a Silurian?" (Doctor Who and the Silurians)

"Then why do you need so many people to keep them under control? Don't they like being happy and prosperous?" (Day of the Daleks)

"Courage isn't just a matter of not being frightened, you know." (Planet of the Daleks)

"Save me a piece of wedding cake." (The Green Death)

-----​

I hope I'll travel with you again someday, Jon. Until then, it's on to Season Twelve and Robot.


(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 13 April 2021.)

Doctor Who, Season Eleven

Here's another victory lap for the books. The fifth and final Pertwee season is now wrapped up! It's been a curious thing; while certainly not a bad season by any means, after four seasons which seemed so confident in what they were doing, Season Eleven feels like something of an afterthought. This is more of a coda to an era - but nevertheless, a nice coda.

For the roster of writers, we're only missing Baker & Martin for a who's-who of the Pertwee era. Yet another excellent Bob Holmes story is joined by the last scripts from Hulke, Hayles, and the Sloman-Letts duo, and the increasingly rare contribution from Terry Nation. It's sad to see the last contributions from several of these people, but it's good that things are changing and staying fresh. With the benefit of hindsight, it does seem very obvious that Holmes is gearing up to take over the position of script editor, and I'm excited to see how that goes for him.

Here's the score breakdown:

The Time Warrior - 9.50
Part One - 10.00
Part Two - 9.00
Part Three - 10.00
Part Four - 9.00

Invasion of the Dinosaurs - 8.50
Part One - 9.00
Part Two - 9.00
Part Three - 8.00
Part Four - 8.00
Part Five - 8.00
Part Six - 9.00

Death to the Daleks - 5.75
Part One - 8.00
Part Two - 6.00
Part Three - 5.00
Part Four - 4.00

The Monster of Peladon - 5.67
Part One - 6.00
Part Two - 5.00
Part Three - 5.00
Part Four - 6.00
Part Five - 6.00
Part Six - 6.00

Planet of the Spiders - 7.50
Part One - 8.00
Part Two - 7.00
Part Three - 7.00
Part Four - 7.00
Part Five - 7.00
Part Six - 9.00

Best episode: The Time Warrior, Part One - 10.00
Runner-up: The Time Warrior, Part Three - 10.00
Worst episode: Death to the Daleks, Part Four - 4.00

Season Eleven average: 7.35

Best guest appearance: Kevin Lindsay as Commander Linx (The Time Warrior)
Best special effect: The Exxilon city (Death to the Daleks)
Best musical score: Death to the Daleks (Carey Blyton)

The 1974 music post will be coming soon.

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 13 April 2021.)

Saturday, April 10, 2021

Doctor Who, Season Ten

Most shows don't look great during their tenth years. Hell, most shows don't make it to their tenth years. I think we must recognize the fact that it's a miracle that Doctor Who survived the chopping block several times to make it to this point, let alone that it eventually made it to year twenty-six - going on sixty! For all that Season Ten celebrated the legacy of the program in a way that nothing before it did, it does not show its age for even a moment. Although the program's issues with six-part stories are still evident, there isn't a single bad episode in this season. Pound for pound, it's one of the best the show's ever made.

It was with a heavy heart that I said goodbye to Jo Grant and to Delgado's Master, both of whom I came to love over the previous three seasons. It feels like time is not on the Third Doctor's side anymore, and soon things must change.

Here's the score breakdown:

The Three Doctors - 8.50
Episode One - 9.00
Episode Two - 8.00
Episode Three - 9.00
Episode Four - 8.00

Carnival of Monsters - 10.00
Episode One - 10.00
Episode Two - 10.00
Episode Three - 10.00
Episode Four - 10.00

Frontier in Space - 8.67
Episode One - 9.00
Episode Two - 9.00
Episode Three - 9.00
Episode Four - 8.00
Episode Five - 8.00
Episode Six - 9.00

Planet of the Daleks - 7.33
Episode One - 9.00
Episode Two - 7.00
Episode Three - 7.00
Episode Four - 7.00
Episode Five - 7.00
Episode Six - 7.00

The Green Death - 9.83
Episode One - 10.00
Episode Two - 10.00
Episode Three - 10.00
Episode Four - 10.00
Episode Five - 9.00
Episode Six - 10.00

Best episode: The Green Death, Episode Six - 10.00
Runner-up: Carnival of Monsters, Episode Two - 10.00
"Worst" episode: Planet of the Daleks, Episode Five - 7.00

Season Ten average: 8.81

Best guest appearance: John Dearth as BOSS (The Green Death)
Best special effect: The maggots (The Green Death)
Best musical score: Carnival of Monsters (Dudley Simpson)

Here's to one last season with Jon Pertwee, whose tenure has seemed to fly by even if it is chronologically the longest so far. We'll pick up Season Eleven with The Time Warrior presently.

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 9 April 2021.)

Doctor Who, Season Nine

Can I really already be past the halfway point of the Pertwee era? After the first baby steps to Uxareius in the last season, the show is at last stretching its wings again and untethering itself from the Season Seven format. Three of this season's five stories had no appearances from the UNIT crew at all, even if one of those three is still earthbound. In the midst of it all, Jon Pertwee goes from strength to strength, now thoroughly inhabiting the role of the Doctor in ways that his predecessors rarely did. After her shaky start last season, Katy Manning likewise continues to convince as Jo Grant.

We visited the future, other worlds, and the English Channel (!) and had a lot of fun along the way. I'm finding myself comfortable in this era at this point, and I'm really, really looking forward to what comes next.

But first, here's the score breakdown:

Day of the Daleks - 9.25
Episode One - 10.00
Episode Two - 9.00
Episode Three - 9.00
Episode Four - 9.00

The Curse of Peladon - 8.25
Episode One - 8.00
Episode Two - 8.00
Episode Three - 8.00
Episode Four - 9.00

The Sea Devils - 8.33
Episode One - 9.00
Episode Two - 9.00
Episode Three - 9.00
Episode Four - 7.00
Episode Five - 8.00
Episode Six - 8.00

The Mutants - 7.83
Episode One - 8.00
Episode Two - 7.00
Episode Three - 7.00
Episode Four - 8.00
Episode Five - 8.00
Episode Six - 9.00

The Time Monster - 6.17
Episode One - 6.00
Episode Two - 6.00
Episode Three - 5.00
Episode Four - 6.00
Episode Five - 7.00
Episode Six - 7.00

Best episode: Day of the Daleks, Episode One - 10.00
Runner-up: Day of the Daleks, Episode Three - 9.00
Worst episode: The Time Monster, Episode Three - 5.00

Season Nine average: 7.85

Best guest appearance: Aubrey Woods as the Controller (Day of the Daleks)
Best special effect: The Sea Devil costumes (The Sea Devils)
Best musical score: The Sea Devils (Malcolm Clarke)

Now for a musical interlude for 1972, before we get to the next stories.

(Modified from the original posted on Gallifrey Base on 3 April 2021.)