Saturday, June 25, 2022

Cities Made of Song, 1981

Cities Made of Song, 1981 - Veteran of the Psychic Wars by Blue Öyster Cult

I'm not going to have to copy the funny O every damn time I name the band in this post, am I?

The 1970s were a flourishing time in the American rock scene, but if I were one to make sweeping and unsubstantiated statements, and let's say I am for the moment, I'd contend that few were as innovative as Blue Öyster Cult.

Affectionately nicknamed BÖC by their fans (and by anyone else disinclined to say or type all of that), this band had their start, like so many of the others that I've touched upon so far, in the thriving club scene of the late 1960s, at first as Soft White Underbelly, before blossoming into a successful psychedelic rock group in the 1970s.

As with any group, there is plenty of room for spirited disagreement over which album actually represents the best of their work. "Cultösaurus Erectus" and "Agents of Fortune" both stand out for me as examples. Still, I'd have to say that "Fire of Unknown Origin" represents the cream of this particular crop.

Being fresh off a long streak of successful albums, "Fire of Unknown Origin" would sadly mark the end of BÖC's heyday in the minds of many, but judged on its own merits, I think it's a superb crossover of hard rock, psych/prog, and metal influences that really sounds like nothing else.

How was I introduced to this particular record, you might ask? Why, none other than a Doctor Who AMV. For those not in the know, this acronym is being slightly misappropriated. It stands for "anime music video", a mashup with music playing, and clips from a show superimposed over it. It started as a trend ages ago in that particular subculture, before spreading via cultural osmosis to include similar mashups of live action shows. This specific video, which sadly no longer exists, coupled the BÖC song Veteran of the Psychic Wars with footage of Sylvester McCoy's Seventh Doctor, and I was immediately intrigued.

The lyrics are beguiling, telling the story of the titular veteran who has fought so many battles and given up so much that he isn't sure how to carry on anymore. It's possible to draw any number of parallels. This song was recorded in the wake of Vietnam and in the midst of an increasing epidemic of drug use, after all. And while these parallels were seemingly intended, I was interested to learn that the song is more directly based on a certain work of fiction, namely Michael Moorcock's Eternal Champion series.

It's a pretty massive series, and difficult to explain. Doubly so since I've shamefully never taken the chance to read it. Essentially, it focuses on a cosmic battle between the forces of Law and Chaos across the multiverse. In every instance, there is a different incarnation of the same Champion who is meant to achieve balance between the two. This Champion appears in all different guises, different races, and different genders, but is always one aspect of the same being who is partly conscious of the infinite wars they have fought.

It's a sobering concept, but definitely a somewhat familiar one for a Doctor Who fan. This is very close to the way I've always conceived of the Doctor as a character. The role is especially reminiscent of the Seventh Doctor and his mantle of Time's Champion, and the struggle between Law and Chaos bears an amusing similarity to that between the Black and White Guardians, who we'll be revisiting soon enough.

I've always found something particularly intriguing about immortal, ageless, or reincarnated characters, which I suppose is part of what drew me to Doctor Who in the first place. It's always a treat when this particular trait of the Doctor's is played upon, and as we press on, this song's portrayal of a timeless champion struggling to carry on will be more and more appropriate.

That musical interlude thus checked off, it's finally time for Castrovalva. See you then!

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 14 December 2021.)

K-9 and Company: A Girl's Best Friend [Doctor Who, Diversion 30]

K-9 and Company: A Girl's Best Friend by Terence Dudley
28 December 1981​

Funny coincidence, writing up this review right around this thing's fortieth birthday. Coming from a world which saw first the successful spinoffs of the Russell T. Davies years and then the Marvel television universe boom, it is acutely strange to see an attempt at a Doctor Who spinoff program at such an early date. I was not entirely sure what to expect from this going in except for a hilarious opening theme.

All things considered, I found this story perfectly harmless Christmas season viewing, but kept asking myself one question over and over again: who was this for?

With Torchwood or the Sarah Jane Adventures, that's a pretty easy question to answer. Torchwood was meant to engage with the older side of Doctor Who's age range, and SJA the younger. What demographic was K-9 and Company supposed to appeal to? It just feels like more Doctor Who. Only, perhaps, less of it.

There are a few noticeable tonal differences. For example, I was kept waiting the whole runtime for the alien face behind the threat of the witch's coven to show itself, only to remain befuddled when it just ended up being a bunch of rural folk in robes. For a show named after a robot dog, there is nary a trace of science fiction to be found.

Aside from a few odd details (like Aunt Lavinia's confounding reappearance and Sarah's inexplicable skill in judo) this story mostly ran in through one of my ears and dribbled out the other. It seems like the sort of television that's best enjoyed the night after Christmas while imperfectly sober. It's not bad, but I can't fault anyone for not greenlighting more of it. Sarah and K-9 will, nevertheless, have another, better shot at this a ways down the road. All the power to them.

That detour done, there is another quick one I wanted to get to before we start to dig into Peter Davison's Doctor Who. Namely, our first Cities Made of Song in a while. See you then.

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 14 December 2021.)

A Word on Tom Baker

A Word on Tom Baker​

The phrase "larger than life" is so often overused, but I feel it's impossible to go wrong when applying it to Tom Baker. Many actors in leading roles have rather oversized personalities, particularly in a show like Doctor Who which prides itself on the unusual and quirky. Baker still stands head and shoulders above the rest of them in that respect, and not just in the literal sense. It is this, in part, which has affixed him as the definitive Doctor in the minds of generations of fans, but that isn't the whole story. It helps that he's a tremendously capable actor, and one who was served well by some of the best seasons in the show's history.

That is not to say that his whole run has been comprised of the best seasons in the show's history. I disagreed with the tone of bits of the Hinchcliffe-Holmes era, and some episodes in the Williams era really were shockingly shoddy. But no matter how badly things went in the writer's room or the BBC boardrooms, you could be assured a certain level of quality simply by virtue of Tom's outrageous performances.

Such a small post is really no way to really measure the accomplishments of the Fourth Doctor era, but I hope it should suffice to say that even if this version of the Time Lord did not enter the ranks of my absolute favorites, it is very hard to imagine where Doctor Who would be without him.

-----​

Just like Pertwee before him, Tom has seen quite a few companions come and go, which has shaken up my companions ranking list a fair bit. Let's see what has changed since 1974.

  1. Barbara Wright
  2. Jo Grant
  3. Romana II
  4. Jamie McCrimmon
  5. Steven Taylor
  6. Liz Shaw
  7. Leela of the Sevateem
  8. Vicki Pallister
  9. Sarah Jane Smith
  10. Ian Chesterton

The only casualties are the Brig and Zoe, both fine companions in their own right, but the competition will only get more stiff from here on out.

Sarah Jane Smith remains at #9, but actually jumps ahead of two people after her second and third seasons on the show. She's tremendously likable, but I found it hard to say I liked her better than the others here. However, she is in the unique position of having several more seasons later in the marathon to ascend further. We wish her the best.

Leela charmed me a whole lot during her relatively short time on the show. Feisty and vivacious, and far outside of the norm for companions so far, she is immediately emblematic of her particular time on the show, and Louise Jameson is so lovely. I was very sorry to see her go when she did.

Romana I does not quite make it onto the list here. Mary Tamm put in a very convincing performance, but her single season wasn't quite enough for me to warm to her as I might have liked. It is especially hard with such a fantastic performance from her successor.

Speaking of whom, Romana II was a surprise and a delight. Her sense of style and her combination of aristocratic airs with cheeky playfulness were a winning combination of traits. The TARDIS team of her, Four, and K-9 is honestly hard to beat.

K-9 himself is a notable absence from this list, but please trust me when I say that I love that dog. (In fact, we're getting another dose shortly...)

Adric, Nyssa, and Tegan were omitted from my judgements when I compiled this list. They have simply not had the time to prove themselves yet. Expect to hear more over the course of the next few seasons.

-----​

It's hard to do a 'best of' reel for Tom without sounding like I'm cribbing notes from YouTube clip shows. And after all, it is a bit difficulty to pick "stand-out" moments from someone whose on-screen presence was pretty much always dialed to 11. Regardless, here are five of my favorite moments from Tom Baker's tenure as Doctor Who:

"Homo sapiens. What an inventive, invincible species." (The Ark in Space)

"Have I that right?" (Genesis of the Daleks)

"What do you do for an encore, Doctor?" "I win." (The Seeds of Doom)

"Would you mind not standing on my chest? My hat is on fire." (The Androids of Tara)

"Where are we going?" "Are you talking philosophically or geographically?" "Philosophically." "Then we're going to lunch." (City of Death)

-----​

And so the longest leg of this journey is at its end, and though I am sorry to bid farewell to the Fourth Doctor, I am excited to chart the unknown waters of the greater JNT era. Bye-bye, Tom! Bye-bye!

Speaking of unknown waters, though, I think I'm about to scupper myself on a deserted island just ahead. Doctor Who's first spinoff is next...

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 14 December 2021.)

Doctor Who, Season Eighteen

As far as a statement of intent from a new production team goes, Season Eighteen is a pretty good example of one that went right. Although I will happily defend the Williams era from the worst of its detractors, it is hard to deny the whiff of fresh air that wafts through with JNT's first season. Courtesy of the writers involved with this stellar season, it feels like there is a common thematic thread through all these episodes, something which is still rare in the show at this point. Although there were a couple of rough patches, it was a very solid year of Doctor Who.

That is where it rests as a prologue to the remainder of the Eighties, but what about as a coda for Tom? It does feel like he's working his notice at times, and everyone knows he was not particularly happy by the end. Still, although this feels very much apart from the seasons before it, it seems like this feeling of renewal is appropriate for the end of such a long reign.

Here's the score breakdown:​

The Leisure Hive - 8.00
Part One - 9.00
Part Two - 8.00
Part Three - 8.00
Part Four - 7.00

Meglos - 5.00
Part One - 5.00
Part Two - 5.00
Part Three - 5.00
Part Four - 5.00

Full Circle - 9.00
Part One - 9.00
Part Two - 9.00
Part Three - 9.00
Part Four - 9.00

State of Decay - 9.25
Part One - 9.00
Part Two - 9.00
Part Three - 10.00
Part Four - 9.00

Warriors' Gate - 10.00
Part One - 10.00
Part Two - 10.00
Part Three - 10.00
Part Four - 10.00

The Keeper of Traken - 6.75
Part One - 7.00
Part Two - 7.00
Part Three - 7.00
Part Four - 6.00

Logopolis - 9.00
Part One - 10.00
Part Two - 9.00
Part Three - 8.00
Part Four - 9.00

Best episode: Warriors' Gate, Part Four - 10.00
Runner-up: Warriors' Gate, Part One - 10.00
Worst episode: Meglos, Part Three - 5.00

Season Eighteen average: 8.14

Best guest appearance: Jacqueline Hill as Lexa (Meglos)
Best special effect: The Doctor is disassembled (The Leisure Hive)
Best musical score: Logopolis (Paddy Kingsland)

And now, to tip my hat to Tom. I will be along with that post shortly.

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 14 December 2021.)

Logopolis [Doctor Who, Story 115]

Logopolis by Christopher H. Bidmead
28 February - 21 March 1981

Watching this in the context of the marathon was a strange experience, since happenstance has conspired to have me watch this story twice previously, making this viewing the third. It's definitely a lot more bittersweet after seven seasons of Tom Baker. It feels rather like parting from an old friend.

There is a sort of cosmic unfairness to the whole affair, as the Doctor dies surrounded not by those he loves, but by perfect strangers who have been foisted upon him over the course of this season. "I've never chosen my company," he bites out at Nyssa once in this story, and it's hard not to feel sympathetic to him. Still, there is a bit of relief to be found in his final thoughts of all the friends this incarnation has had, and his smile at the end, seemingly sure that things will be okay.

The whole thing about computing matter out of mathematics and the tide of entropy doesn't really make a lick of sense, as much as I try to puzzle it over, but I can't bring myself to care about that too much. The atmosphere of this story is impeccable, and it more than makes up for any other deficiencies. I actually think Tegan has a rather strong character introduction, even if her kvetching begins to grate by the final part, and the Doctor's weary resignation for once feels apropos. Paddy Kingsland's superb soundtrack is the icing on top.

If there was any one thing in the writing of this episode that I'd truly feel like complaining about, it would be the shocking lack of pathos surrounding Traken's destruction. Poor Nyssa takes it with barely a whimper and a bat of the eye, and then it doesn't seem to come up again. What kind of story wastes the dramatic potential of a character losing their entire people? (Not now, Flux, you'll have your turn in a few years.)

Quibbles aside, I think that a goodbye for a Time Lord quite like this one is almost an impossibly tall order. The fact that Logopolis manages the task in some measure is an accomplishment. I think I'll certainly enjoy rewatching this one again.

That's all there is to say on that. Our roundup for Season 18 will come next, and then a farewell to the Fourth Doctor.

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 14 December 2021.)

The Keeper of Traken [Doctor Who, Story 114]

The Keeper of Traken by Johnny Byrne
31 January - 21 February 1981

"A whole empire held together by... Well, by people just being terribly nice to each other."​

After a somewhat protracted pause (busy with trying and failing to write a novel, don't you know), I find myself with the unenviable task of trying to spin a review out of my memories of this episode, memories which are now about two months old. I do not mean to be uncharitable to the old thing, but there is very little that has actually remained with me about The Keeper of Traken in that span of time, apart from getting to see the crispy Master again.

This is not a bad story, but it is also certainly not a particularly exciting one. I feel I did not get the intended experience of getting to enjoy the mystery of the Melkur, having been spoiled on the Master's presence in this story years ago. Would I have held it in higher esteem if it were a surprise to me? Maybe. I have a feeling that Part 3 might still have put me to sleep, however.

Tom feels adrift without Lalla around. I'm certain he was unhappy, now having only Matthew Waterhouse's Adric for a counterpart. He seems pretty snippy, and while it suits the funereal air of his impending regeneration, I can't say that it really makes for enjoyable watching.

Nyssa's introduction is noticed by me, but not much remarked upon in my notes. I don't think she was meant to become a real companion when this story was authored; if she was, I'd be shocked, because we get to know her very little. I'm sure she'll be fine once she's working full-time.

The sets are fairly nice. I like the garden the best. I can't say that Traken feels like much of a living world aside from that. More like a nursing home.

All these points aside, there's very little that I can scrape together from my memory, or even from the notes I took. Just as well to get working on these posts again. It's nearly the end. Logopolis is next.

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 14 December 2021.)

Warriors' Gate [Doctor Who, Story 113]

Warriors' Gate by Steve Gallagher
3 - 24 January 1981

"Do nothing, if it's the right sort of nothing."​

My first immediate thought upon starting Warriors' Gate was that it was directed with some youthful energy. I'm not sure exactly how old Paul Joyce was in 1981, but it definitely feels like a completely new directorial style for the show. It feeds a lot of life into scenes which might otherwise be compositionally lacking because of the majority of this story taking place in a white void. In spite of the lack of background variation, there are a number of striking images, including the Gate sitting in the middle of the void, or the survey crew scoping out the TARDIS.

As for the content of the story, I think I just about managed to understand it. Warriors' Gate certainly doesn't make it easy; it is a beguiling beast with a lot of suggestion and metaphor involved. That said, I found the story of the Tharils, their former warmongering ways, and now their enslavement to be quite affecting. The more philosophical undertones of how Biroc uses his knowledge of the web of time to free his people, and doing something versus doing nothing, went over my head a bit; I confess that I resorted to reading a few articles analyzing the story to the point where I felt comfortable going "Ohhh, so that's how it is..."

Still, I don't think complexity is a mark against the story; it just means that it's a serial that will reward repeat viewings, which I'm always happy to have an excuse for. This was my experience with Ghost Light too, so I expect this one to evolve into a favorite over time. (Oops, spoilers.)

The slaver crew are pretty well-illustrated characters. Rorvik's cruelty and single-mindedness are good villain traits; I gasped a bit at the scene toward the end where he stomps on the Doctor's hand. Aldo and Royce are a very good example of the "tall guy/small guy" comic duo, their nine-to-five bad guy gig obviously being a bit of a joke to them. Their little chinwag about their "all-in contract" got a dark chuckle out of me.

Probably the most emotional part of this story for me is Romana's farewell, however. I've liked Romana a lot, and especially Lalla Ward's take on the character for these last couple of seasons. Her dynamic with the Doctor has been excellent, as has her development from sidekick to a leading character in her own right; here in particular I think of the scene where she steps out of the TARDIS in this story to confront the slavers outside. She leads that conversation effortlessly in the same sort of way the Doctor would. It makes her departure at this point feel more poignant, because she really has grown all she can while still being under the Doctor's wing. It's time for her to spread her own wings and fly.

(Also, Adric was in this one.)

All in all, a stunning story, and a true piece of art. I'm pleased that this little trilogy has ended on such a high. The Keeper of Traken is next.

 "I'll miss you. You were the noblest Romana of them all."​

(Modified from the original posted at Gallifrey Base on 24 October 2021.)